Holbrook vs Holbrook XL vs Holbrook Mix: How to Tell Them Apart

Oakley®'s Holbrook, Holbrook XL and Holbrook Mix look almost identical at a glance, yet none of them takes another's lens. Before ordering replacement lenses, an owner needs to know exactly which frame is on the table, and the steps below show how to find out.

Holbrook frame

Quick comparison

Frame Model number Lens width How to tell it apart Replacement lenses
Holbrook OO9102 55 mm The standard Holbrook has an all-O Matter frame with metal-look front rivets and a Square O temple icon, and its left arm reads OO9102 with a 55 mm lens width. Lenses for the Holbrook
Holbrook XL OO9417 59 mm The Holbrook XL looks like the standard model but is Oakley's wide-fit version, and its left arm reads OO9417 with a 59 mm lens width. Lenses for the Holbrook XL
Holbrook Mix OO9384 57 mm The Holbrook Mix pairs an O Matter centre with stainless-steel temples and black Unobtainium grip sections, and its left arm reads OO9384 with a 57 mm lens width. Lenses for the Holbrook Mix

How to tell which one you have

  1. Open the sunglasses and look inside the left temple arm. Oakley prints the model number first, then the colour code, then the size; on a standard Holbrook it reads like "OO9102-01 55□18 137".
  2. Match the first part of that marking: OO9102 is the Holbrook, OO9417 is the Holbrook XL and OO9384 is the Holbrook Mix. The code after the dash describes the colour variant, not the frame.
  3. Read the lens width, which is the first number before the square symbol. The Holbrook measures 55 mm, the Holbrook Mix 57 mm and the Holbrook XL 59 mm. If the print has worn away, measure one lens across its widest point.
  4. Check the temples. Stainless-steel arms with black rubbery grip sections mean Holbrook Mix; moulded O Matter arms with a Square O icon point to the Holbrook or the Holbrook XL.
  5. If the frame is still undecided between Holbrook and Holbrook XL, let the lens width settle it: both share an 18 mm bridge and a 137 mm arm, so the 55 mm versus 59 mm lens is the real difference.

Which lenses fit which frame

None of these three frames shares a lens with another. A Holbrook lens will not fit a Holbrook XL or a Holbrook Mix, a Holbrook XL lens will not fit a Holbrook or a Holbrook Mix, and a Holbrook Mix lens will not fit either of the other two. The shapes are close enough to fool the eye, but the lens widths differ by several millimetres, which is enough for a lens to sit loose or refuse to seat at all. Whether an owner orders Walleva replacement lenses or customized lenses from elsewhere, the order should be matched to the model number printed on the arm rather than to the general Holbrook name.

Why the size labels can mislead

Oakley's current listings describe both the Holbrook and the Holbrook XL as "XL" with a 140 mm overall frame width, so the size label alone will not separate them; the model number and the fit designation will. The Holbrook is listed as Regular / High Bridge Fit, while the Holbrook XL is Wide / High Bridge Fit. The Holbrook Mix adds another twist: it carries an "L" label yet measures 135 mm overall, narrower than both. Oakley also makes the Holbrook in sizes from S through XXL, plus an Asia Fit version, so an owner of a non-standard Holbrook should rely on the lens width printed on their own arm rather than assume 55 mm.

Frames and lenses that only look related

The Holbrook Metal is a separate frame built from C-5 metal and listed at 134 mm wide; it is not one of the three covered here and should not be confused with the Holbrook Mix, which keeps an O Matter centre. Likewise, the lens itself says little about the frame: Prizm, polarized and standard sunglass lenses are simply variants offered across the family. The 1940s-to-1960s styling Oakley built the Holbrook around is shared by all three, which is exactly why the arm marking matters more than appearance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Holbrook lens be fitted into a Holbrook XL?

No. The Holbrook uses a 55 mm lens and the Holbrook XL a 59 mm lens, and the two are not interchangeable in either direction.

Where exactly is the model number on a Holbrook frame?

Inside the left temple arm. The first part of the marking, such as OO9102, OO9417 or OO9384, identifies the model; the numbers that follow give the colour code and the size.

Does a polarized or Prizm lens mean the frame is a different model?

No. Lens colour and lens technology are separate variants and do not identify the frame. For sunglass or optical use alike, the frame's model number decides which lens will fit.

Walleva is an independent maker of replacement lenses and is not affiliated with, sponsored by or endorsed by Oakley, Ray-Ban, Maui Jim, Costa Del Mar, Smith Optics, Wiley X, Bollé, POC or any other eyewear brand. Brand and model names are trademarks of their respective owners and are used only to identify the frames our replacement lenses are made to fit.